{
  "original": {
    "score": 43,
    "scores": {
      "brand_fit": 3.5,
      "visual_distinctiveness": 4,
      "hierarchy_clarity": 4,
      "responsive_quality": 4.5,
      "accessibility": 5.5
    },
    "basis": "Root design critique of 375/768/1440 Chrome screenshots. Sale badge and expanded chat/cookie overlays obscure browsing; mixed typography; desktop layout overflows narrower viewport even after reload. This is a subjective design rubric, not a user conversion study or full accessibility certification."
  },
  "info": {
    "assemblage": {
      "name": "Assemblage",
      "color": "#657818",
      "final_round": "image-delivery",
      "legibility_round": "image-delivery-legibility",
      "motion_video": "evidence/assemblage/pass3-motion/page@6f3aa1d8082db49dd12000506299c804.webm"
    },
    "perspective": {
      "name": "Perspective",
      "color": "#18545b",
      "final_round": "image-delivery-final",
      "legibility_round": "image-delivery-legibility-fix"
    },
    "chromatic": {
      "name": "Chromatic",
      "color": "#8b405e",
      "final_round": "image-delivery-final",
      "legibility_round": "image-performance-fix2",
      "motion_video": "evidence/chromatic/pass3-motion/motion.webm"
    },
    "showroom-flight": {
      "name": "Showroom Flight",
      "color": "#8a6a36",
      "final_round": "image-delivery",
      "legibility_round": "image-delivery-legibility",
      "status": "Archive-film prototype"
    }
  },
  "concepts": {
    "assemblage": [
      {
        "run": 1,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.399043+00:00",
        "candidate": "baseline",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 8,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 8.5,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 7.5,
          "responsive_quality": 8,
          "accessibility": 9
        },
        "total": 41.0,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": null,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "a7176373fa78e9dcf0d54b9611cc0cc108dbbe2e2ef6ad1199f329f809718be1",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/assemblage/baseline"
        ],
        "notes": "Strong clipped-photo direction; old hero words and floating controls violated latest brief. Gallery scale and lower text spacing remained unresolved. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 82.0,
        "evidence_round": "baseline",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/assemblage/baseline/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/assemblage/baseline/375-full.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 2,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.401716+00:00",
        "candidate": "craft",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 8.6,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 8.8,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 8.7,
          "responsive_quality": 9.1,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 44.6,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 41.0,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "a7176373fa78e9dcf0d54b9611cc0cc108dbbe2e2ef6ad1199f329f809718be1",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/assemblage/refinement-1"
        ],
        "notes": "Exact foreground brand and reserved action space. Functional gates pass; gallery caption and Form-copy collision required the next pass. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 89.2,
        "evidence_round": "refinement-1",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/assemblage/refinement-1/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/assemblage/refinement-1/375-full.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 3,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.403414+00:00",
        "candidate": "design-push",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 9,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9.1,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 9.2,
          "responsive_quality": 9.1,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 45.8,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 44.6,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "a7176373fa78e9dcf0d54b9611cc0cc108dbbe2e2ef6ad1199f329f809718be1",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/assemblage/pass2"
        ],
        "notes": "Larger active product, hidden inactive captions, separated Form text and spatial chapter composition; Chrome11 journeys pass. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 91.6,
        "evidence_round": "pass2",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/assemblage/pass2/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/assemblage/pass2/375-full.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 4,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.404812+00:00",
        "candidate": "polish",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 9,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9.1,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 9.3,
          "responsive_quality": 9.2,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 46.0,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 45.8,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "a7176373fa78e9dcf0d54b9611cc0cc108dbbe2e2ef6ad1199f329f809718be1",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/assemblage/pass3"
        ],
        "notes": "Root inspected current desktop/mobile and full page. Circular plane compositing, image preload and action contrast corrected. Chrome/WebKit11 journeys and expanded legibility31 states pass. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 92.0,
        "evidence_round": "pass3",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/assemblage/pass3/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/assemblage/pass3/375-full.webp"
      }
    ],
    "perspective": [
      {
        "run": 1,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.406498+00:00",
        "candidate": "baseline",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 8.3,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 8.6,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 7.8,
          "responsive_quality": 8.2,
          "accessibility": 9
        },
        "total": 41.9,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": null,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "088e01ea36f50b3db8f6bda010d5a0bcaa2882f2760fe2189db568b0c72a4c03",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/perspective/baseline-full"
        ],
        "notes": "Clear petrol/copper architectural direction with photographic depth. Caption projection, text/photo clearance and Safari mouse focus needed correction. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 83.8,
        "evidence_round": "baseline-full",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/perspective/baseline-full/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/perspective/baseline-full/375-full.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 2,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.408714+00:00",
        "candidate": "craft",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 8.7,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 8.8,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 8.5,
          "responsive_quality": 8.8,
          "accessibility": 9.3
        },
        "total": 44.1,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 41.9,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "088e01ea36f50b3db8f6bda010d5a0bcaa2882f2760fe2189db568b0c72a4c03",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/perspective/legibility-1-fix"
        ],
        "notes": "Foreground brand and clear hero geometry; copy separated from consignment photo. Heading checks pass; lower component material treatment remained underdeveloped. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 88.2,
        "evidence_round": "legibility-1-fix",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/perspective/legibility-1-fix/1440-legibility.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/perspective/legibility-1-fix/375-legibility.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 3,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.410075+00:00",
        "candidate": "design-push",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 9,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9.1,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 8.9,
          "responsive_quality": 9,
          "accessibility": 9.3
        },
        "total": 45.3,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 44.1,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "088e01ea36f50b3db8f6bda010d5a0bcaa2882f2760fe2189db568b0c72a4c03",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/perspective/pass2-after"
        ],
        "notes": "Copper extruded picture frames, active caption bases and composed final catalog spread. Removed backplane lettering after root/agent visual review. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 90.6,
        "evidence_round": "pass2-after",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/perspective/pass2-after/1440-carousel.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/perspective/pass2-after/375-carousel.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 4,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:40:23.411300+00:00",
        "candidate": "polish",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 9,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9.1,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 9.1,
          "responsive_quality": 9.2,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 45.8,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 45.3,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "088e01ea36f50b3db8f6bda010d5a0bcaa2882f2760fe2189db568b0c72a4c03",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/perspective/pass3-final"
        ],
        "notes": "Root inspected current desktop/mobile plus gallery/catalog. Static foreground brand, responsive image selection and visibility cleanup. Chrome/WebKit11 journeys and legibility29 states pass. Retrospective root critique of saved evidence; recording-time tree hash is current source, not a historical snapshot. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 91.6,
        "evidence_round": "pass3-final",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/perspective/pass3-final/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/perspective/pass3-final/375-full.webp"
      }
    ],
    "chromatic": [
      {
        "run": 1,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:47:16.064134+00:00",
        "candidate": "baseline",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 8.3,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 8.8,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 8.1,
          "responsive_quality": 8.2,
          "accessibility": 9
        },
        "total": 42.4,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": null,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "bf4c1b28d9fbcc59b5ca9327042fa0fd9558bf874b3b22f14d8090249d4cac72",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/chromatic/initial"
        ],
        "notes": "Custom shader apertures and coral/plum composition established; original heroine wording, depth-buffer stripe and mobile dock needed correction. Retrospective root visual critique; current source hash is not a historical screenshot-time hash. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 84.8,
        "evidence_round": "initial",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/chromatic/initial/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/chromatic/initial/375-full.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 2,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:47:16.075411+00:00",
        "candidate": "craft",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 8.7,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 8.8,
          "responsive_quality": 8.9,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 44.8,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 42.4,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "bf4c1b28d9fbcc59b5ca9327042fa0fd9558bf874b3b22f14d8090249d4cac72",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/chromatic/legibility-2"
        ],
        "notes": "Exact foreground brand, depth artifact corrected and mobile dock removed;33 states passed before the broader paragraph checks. Retrospective root visual critique; current source hash is not a historical screenshot-time hash. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 89.6,
        "evidence_round": "legibility-2",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/chromatic/legibility-2/1440-legibility.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/chromatic/legibility-2/375-legibility.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 3,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:47:16.081369+00:00",
        "candidate": "design-push",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 9,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9.3,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 9.1,
          "responsive_quality": 9,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 45.8,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 44.8,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "bf4c1b28d9fbcc59b5ca9327042fa0fd9558bf874b3b22f14d8090249d4cac72",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/chromatic/pass2"
        ],
        "notes": "Custom living-gallery component separates active labels from the picture stack; material-backed catalog and alternative-image controls. Expanded legibility35 states passed. Retrospective root visual critique; current source hash is not a historical screenshot-time hash. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 91.6,
        "evidence_round": "pass2",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/chromatic/pass2/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/chromatic/pass2/375-full.webp"
      },
      {
        "run": 4,
        "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T19:47:16.087395+00:00",
        "candidate": "polish",
        "scores": {
          "brand_fit": 9,
          "visual_distinctiveness": 9.3,
          "hierarchy_clarity": 9.2,
          "responsive_quality": 9.1,
          "accessibility": 9.4
        },
        "total": 46.0,
        "max": 50,
        "previous_best": 45.8,
        "status": "keep",
        "site_tree_hash": "bf4c1b28d9fbcc59b5ca9327042fa0fd9558bf874b3b22f14d8090249d4cac72",
        "evidence": [
          ".tmp/snooty-fox/evidence/chromatic/pass3"
        ],
        "notes": "Root inspected desktop/mobile hero and living gallery. Active metadata is readable, independent WebGL planes and pause have captured evidence. Final browser and performance gates reported separately. Retrospective root visual critique; current source hash is not a historical screenshot-time hash. Internal judgment only; user approval remains pending.",
        "score": 92.0,
        "evidence_round": "pass3",
        "evidence_desktop": "evidence/chromatic/pass3/1440-full.webp",
        "evidence_mobile": "evidence/chromatic/pass3/375-full.webp"
      }
    ]
  },
  "verification": {
    "assemblage": {
      "performance": 99,
      "lcp_ms": 2180.8019999999997,
      "cls": 0,
      "tbt_ms": 18,
      "report": "evidence/assemblage/lighthouse-final.json",
      "measured_at": "2026-09-07T20:13:38.679Z",
      "basis": "Lighthouse13.4.1 default simulated mobile against compressed local package; field performance not measured."
    },
    "perspective": {
      "performance": 92,
      "lcp_ms": 3380.9332000000013,
      "cls": 0,
      "tbt_ms": 13,
      "report": "evidence/perspective/lighthouse-final.json",
      "measured_at": "2026-09-07T20:14:25.518Z",
      "basis": "Lighthouse13.4.1 default simulated mobile against compressed local package; field performance not measured."
    },
    "chromatic": {
      "performance": 96,
      "lcp_ms": 2722.9842,
      "cls": 0.0001865338881004709,
      "tbt_ms": 68.5,
      "report": "evidence/chromatic/lighthouse-final.json",
      "measured_at": "2026-09-07T20:16:04.910Z",
      "basis": "Lighthouse13.4.1 default simulated mobile against compressed local package; field performance not measured."
    },
    "showroom-flight": {
      "performance": 96,
      "lcp_ms": 2782.3169,
      "cls": 0.004640398471511893,
      "tbt_ms": 19,
      "report": "evidence/showroom-flight/lighthouse-final.json",
      "measured_at": "2026-09-07T20:27:32.004Z",
      "basis": "Lighthouse13.4.1 default simulated mobile against compressed local package; field performance not measured."
    }
  },
  "review_status": "Round three; user visual approval pending",
  "history": "review-history.json",
  "basis": "Internal visual critique, not objective beauty measurement. Previous 90+ scores were rejected by the user. Approval is an independent required gate."
}